On 25 April 2025, in La Grand-Combe, in the south of France, a man praying alone in a mosque was stabbed dozens of times. Aboubakar Cissé was 22. Eighteen months later, his death appears, without his name, in the OSCE’s annual hate crime report for 2025. The same report records a homicide committed with both anti-Catholic and disability-related motives. Both killings sit in the same section: incidents in France reported by civil society.

Every year, the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) compiles this report from two sources. The first is official figures submitted by states. The second is incidents reported by civil society organizations, international organizations and the Holy See. The two never fully match, and the report is most revealing in the gap between them.

States are sending less data

For 2025, 45 of the 57 OSCE participating States submitted information. Only 40 provided statistics, and only 30 broke down their police data by bias motivation. Twelve states failed to meet their basic commitment to collect and report this data. Eight of them have not even appointed a national point of contact.

On the civil society side, 103 organizations reported 11,318 incidents across 51 countries, 2,829 of them with a detailed description. ODIHR notes a slight drop in both the number of reporting states and the number of incidents submitted by civil society. It does not read this as a decline in hatred. It attributes it partly to funding cuts that have reduced organizations’ capacity to document cases.

The report highlights a problem common to almost every country. Police record far more offences than prosecutors and courts go on to handle. When the motive is recorded, it is often placed in categories too broad, such as “race” or “religion”, to show which community was actually targeted. Many systems allow only one motive per offence, even though victims are frequently targeted for several reasons at once.

France counts, but does not separate religion

On paper, France performs well. It reports its data regularly, has a specialized central police office (OCLCH), an inter-ministerial delegation (DILCRAH) and an annual victimization survey run by the Interior Ministry’s statistical service. The National Consultative Commission on Human Rights (CNCDH) publishes a yearly report on racism, antisemitism and xenophobia.

In 2025, police and gendarmerie recorded 7,025 hate crimes. 1,440 cases were prosecuted and 1,089 ended in a conviction. These figures do not all concern the same cases or the same year of offence, but the order of magnitude is telling: roughly one case in five reaches a judge.

Threats dominate (2,761 offences), followed by physical assaults (1,457), public order offences (1,013) and property damage (813). Attacks on places of worship account for 523 offences. The figures also include 281 sexual assaults and 18 desecrations of graves.

For freedom of religion, the breakdown by motive is a problem. France reports only two categories: “racism and xenophobia” (4,760 offences) and “anti-LGBTI” (2,265 offences). Anti-religious acts are folded into the first. From the figures sent to the OSCE, it is impossible to know how many Christians, Jews, Muslims or members of other beliefs were targeted for their faith. Yet the country profile on data collection states that police officers can record up to five motives, including religion, and that the central intelligence service has collected specific data on antisemitic and anti-Muslim acts since 2008. The information partly exists. It just does not reach the international level in a usable form.

French law is clear. Article 132-76 of the Criminal Code increases the penalty when an offence is committed because of the victim’s real or perceived membership, or non-membership, of a religion. The 1881 Press Law punishes incitement to hatred on the same grounds. Several circulars have reminded prosecutors to apply this aggravating circumstance: in April 2024 for religion-related offences, in September and October 2025 for antisemitism, and in January 2025 and October 2026 on general criminal policy.

The judicial chain is precisely where ODIHR makes its only key observation on France: the country should strengthen training for prosecutors and judges to prosecute and sentence hate crimes. In 2025, the National School for the Judiciary trained 283 magistrates on racism, antisemitism and xenophobia. Set against the tens of thousands of police officers and gendarmes trained by the OCLCH, the imbalance is clear.

What civil society sees

Seven organizations submitted French incidents to ODIHR for 2025, including LICRA, the Collective Against Islamophobia in Europe, the Observatory on Intolerance and Discrimination against Christians in Europe, the European Association of Jehovah’s Witnesses and the European Office of the Church of Scientology. The Holy See also submitted its own reports.

ODIHR included 331 incidents affecting 295 victims. More than a third involved an anti-Christian motive, mostly attacks on churches and monuments, including several arson attacks on Catholic churches. One detail deserves attention: a large share of the anti-Christian threats, harassment and assaults targeted Jehovah’s Witnesses during their street ministry. These victims rarely feature in the French public debate on anti-religious hatred.

The report records equal numbers of anti-Muslim and antisemitic incidents, with many physical assaults on visibly Jewish or Muslim people. About one fifth of the victims of racist incidents were of Arab or North African origin, and several were children attacked at school or in their neighbourhood. Nearly 15% of incidents involved more than one motive.

ODIHR itself points out the limits of this sample. It received no reports of anti-Roma incidents and very few concerning LGBTI people, people with disabilities, or religions and beliefs classified as “other”. These figures reflect who documents, not necessarily who is most targeted.

That last category concerns us directly. Members of minority religious movements, often labelled “sects” in France, are almost absent from the statistics. This is largely due to underreporting. Many of these victims do not file complaints, because they doubt they will be taken seriously by institutions that see them first as suspects. Victim support services exist, but they are of no use to those who do not dare to turn to them. French police categories, which file anti-religious acts under racism, do nothing to make them visible. ODIHR calls for more precise categories that name the targeted communities. For these believers, it would be the first time the state counted them.

What to watch

Every March, the Interior Ministry’s statistical service publishes its study on racist, xenophobic and anti-religious offences. The March 2027 edition will show whether the repeated instructions to prosecutors have changed the ratio between the 7,025 recorded offences and the 1,089 convictions. The trial of the man charged with the murder of Aboubakar Cissé, indicted for murder aggravated by religious motive, has not yet been scheduled.

Translate »
Share This